Keltner Channels vs McGinley Dynamic Indicator vs Vortex Indicator (VI)
Compact mode

Keltner Channels vs McGinley Dynamic Indicator vs Vortex Indicator (VI)

Table of content

General Information Comparison

Characteristics Comparison

  • Lagging or Leading 🏁
    Indicates whether the trading indicator is a lagging or leading type, reflecting its predictive nature.
    For all*
    • Lagging
      Indicators that confirm trends after they have started

  • Complexity Level 🧑
    Indicates the level of expertise required to effectively use the indicator
    For all*

  • Popularity 🏆
    Indicates how widely used and recognized the indicator is in the trading community
    Keltner Channels
    • Medium
      The popularity of Keltner Channels among traders is considered Medium. Indicators with balanced adoption and potential effectiveness
    McGinley Dynamic Indicator
    • Low
      The popularity of McGinley Dynamic Indicator among traders is considered Low. Indicators with lower adoption but potential unique insights
    Vortex Indicator (VI)
    • Low
      The popularity of Vortex Indicator (VI) among traders is considered Low. Indicators with lower adoption but potential unique insights

Facts Comparison

  • Interesting Fact 💡
    An intriguing or lesser-known fact about the trading indicator
    Keltner Channels
    • Named after Chester Keltner
    McGinley Dynamic Indicator
    • Developed by John R. McGinley to address the lag in traditional moving averages
    Vortex Indicator (VI)
    • Inspired by the vortex concept in fluid dynamics

  • Sarcastic Fact 😉
    A humorous or ironic observation about the trading indicator
    Keltner Channels
    • It's like a bodyguard for price trends keeping them in check
    McGinley Dynamic Indicator
    • So smooth it might make other indicators jealous
    Vortex Indicator (VI)
    • It's like a weather vane for market trends

Application Comparison

  • Timeframe 🕑
    The time intervals or periods for which the trading indicator is most effective or commonly used.
    For all*
    • Daily
      Indicators optimized for daily chart analysis, suitable for swing and position traders.
    Keltner Channels
    • Weekly
      Keltner Channels is most effective for Weekly timeframes. Indicators optimized for weekly chart analysis, balancing short-term noise and long-term trends.
    McGinley Dynamic Indicator
    • Weekly
      McGinley Dynamic Indicator is most effective for Weekly timeframes. Indicators optimized for weekly chart analysis, balancing short-term noise and long-term trends.

Technical Details Comparison

Usage Comparison

Evaluation Comparison

Performance Metrics Comparison

Alternatives to Keltner Channels
Aroon Indicator
Known for Measuring Time Between Highs And Lows
Bollinger Bands
Known for Volatility And Trend Strength
💯 is more reliable than Keltner Channels
🔀 is more versatile than Keltner Channels
⭐ is rated higher overall than Keltner Channels
Moving Average Convergence Divergence (MACD)
Known for Trend Strength And Direction
💻 is easier to use than Keltner Channels
🔀 is more versatile than Keltner Channels
⭐ is rated higher overall than Keltner Channels
Moving Average Envelope
Known for Price Range Visualization
💻 is easier to use than Keltner Channels
⭐ is rated higher overall than Keltner Channels
Chaikin Oscillator
Known for Accumulation/Distribution Trends
Average Directional Index (ADX)
Known for Trend Strength Without Direction
💯 is more reliable than Keltner Channels
Ichimoku Cloud
Known for All-In-One Indicator
🔀 is more versatile than Keltner Channels
⭐ is rated higher overall than Keltner Channels
Donchian Channels
Known for Simplicity And Effectiveness
💯 is more reliable than Keltner Channels
💻 is easier to use than Keltner Channels
⭐ is rated higher overall than Keltner Channels
Choppiness Index
Known for Identifying Trending Vs Choppy Markets
🔀 is more versatile than Keltner Channels
Average True Range (ATR)
Known for Volatility Without Direction
💯 is more reliable than Keltner Channels
💻 is easier to use than Keltner Channels
⭐ is rated higher overall than Keltner Channels