Compact mode
McGinley Dynamic Indicator vs Parabolic SAR vs Elder Impulse System
Table of content
General Information Comparison
Indicator Type 📊
The category or classification of the trading indicator based on its primary function and analysis method.For all*- TrendIndicators that help identify and confirm market trends
Asset Class 💰
Specifies the financial instruments for which the indicator is most commonly usedFor all*McGinley Dynamic IndicatorParabolic SARElder Impulse System- StocksThe asset classes Elder Impulse System is typically used for are Stocks. Indicators optimized for analyzing and predicting stock price movements in equity markets. Click to see all.
- ForexThe asset classes Elder Impulse System is typically used for are Forex. Indicators optimized for currency pair trading in the foreign exchange market. Click to see all.
Known for 💭
The unique selling point or distinguishing feature of the trading indicatorMcGinley Dynamic Indicator- Improving On Traditional Moving AveragesMcGinley Dynamic Indicator is known for Improving On Traditional Moving Averages.
Parabolic SAR- Trend Reversal And Exit PointsParabolic SAR is known for Trend Reversal And Exit Points.
Elder Impulse System- Combining Trend And MomentumElder Impulse System is known for Combining Trend And Momentum.
Made In 🌍
The country or origin of the trading indicatorMcGinley Dynamic IndicatorParabolic SAR- 1978Parabolic SAR was developed in 1978. Trading indicators specifically developed in 1978
Elder Impulse System
Characteristics Comparison
Lagging or Leading 🏁
Indicates whether the trading indicator is a lagging or leading type, reflecting its predictive nature.McGinley Dynamic Indicator- LaggingMcGinley Dynamic Indicator is a Lagging indicator. Indicators that confirm trends after they have started
Parabolic SAR- LaggingParabolic SAR is a Lagging indicator. Indicators that confirm trends after they have started
Elder Impulse SystemComplexity Level 🧑
Indicates the level of expertise required to effectively use the indicatorFor all*Popularity 🏆
Indicates how widely used and recognized the indicator is in the trading communityMcGinley Dynamic Indicator- LowThe popularity of McGinley Dynamic Indicator among traders is considered Low. Indicators with lower adoption but potential unique insights
Parabolic SAR- MediumThe popularity of Parabolic SAR among traders is considered Medium. Indicators with balanced adoption and potential effectiveness
Elder Impulse System- MediumThe popularity of Elder Impulse System among traders is considered Medium. Indicators with balanced adoption and potential effectiveness
Facts Comparison
Interesting Fact 💡
An intriguing or lesser-known fact about the trading indicatorMcGinley Dynamic Indicator- Developed by John R. McGinley to address the lag in traditional moving averages
Parabolic SAR- SAR stands for "Stop And Reverse"
Elder Impulse System- Created by Dr. Alexander Elder a renowned trading psychologist
Sarcastic Fact 😉
A humorous or ironic observation about the trading indicatorMcGinley Dynamic Indicator- So smooth it might make other indicators jealous
Parabolic SAR- It's like a clingy ex - always trying to catch up with the price
Elder Impulse System- Traffic light for traders: green means go red means stop blue means nap time
Application Comparison
Timeframe 🕑
The time intervals or periods for which the trading indicator is most effective or commonly used.For all*- DailyIndicators optimized for daily chart analysis, suitable for swing and position traders.
McGinley Dynamic Indicator- WeeklyMcGinley Dynamic Indicator is most effective for Weekly timeframes. Indicators optimized for weekly chart analysis, balancing short-term noise and long-term trends.
Parabolic SAR- 1-HourParabolic SAR is most effective for 1-Hour timeframes. Indicators optimized for analyzing market data on a 1-hour timeframe
- 4-HourParabolic SAR is most effective for 4-Hour timeframes. Indicators designed for analyzing market data on a 4-hour timeframe
Elder Impulse System- WeeklyElder Impulse System is most effective for Weekly timeframes. Indicators optimized for weekly chart analysis, balancing short-term noise and long-term trends.
Technical Details Comparison
Calculation Method 🧮
The mathematical or analytical approach used to compute the trading indicator's values.McGinley Dynamic IndicatorParabolic SARElder Impulse System- Moving AveragesElder Impulse System uses the Moving Averages calculation method. Indicators combining different moving averages for comprehensive trend analysis. Click to see all.
- MACDElder Impulse System uses the MACD calculation method. Indicators utilizing Moving Average Convergence Divergence for trend and momentum analysis. Click to see all.
Signal Generation 📊
Describes the methods by which the indicator produces trading signalsMcGinley Dynamic Indicator- CrossoversMcGinley Dynamic Indicator generates trading signals through Crossovers. Indicators that generate signals when one line crosses another, indicating trend changes
Parabolic SAR- BreakoutsParabolic SAR generates trading signals through Breakouts. Indicators that identify when price breaks key levels, signaling potential trends
Elder Impulse System- Color-Coded BarsElder Impulse System generates trading signals through Color-Coded Bars. Indicators that color price bars to reflect specific market conditions or signals
Customization Options 🔧
Lists the parameters that can be adjusted to fine-tune the indicatorMcGinley Dynamic Indicator- PeriodMcGinley Dynamic Indicator offers customization options for Period. Enables customization of analysis timeframe Click to see all.
- Smoothing FactorMcGinley Dynamic Indicator offers customization options for Smoothing Factor. Customizable smoothing factor for signal clarity Click to see all.
Parabolic SARElder Impulse System- PeriodElder Impulse System offers customization options for Period. Enables customization of analysis timeframe Click to see all.
- MACD ParametersElder Impulse System offers customization options for MACD Parameters. Allows customization of Moving Average Convergence Divergence parameters Click to see all.
Usage Comparison
For whom 👥
The target audience or user group for the trading indicatorMcGinley Dynamic Indicator- Technical AnalystsMcGinley Dynamic Indicator is designed for Technical Analysts. Provides comprehensive technical analysis tools, crucial for chart pattern recognition Click to see all.
- Trend FollowersMcGinley Dynamic Indicator is designed for Trend Followers. Identifies and confirms long-term market trends, suitable for trend-following strategies Click to see all.
Parabolic SARElder Impulse System- Day TradersElder Impulse System is designed for Day Traders. Tools optimized for short-term intraday trading decisions Click to see all.
- Swing TradersElder Impulse System is designed for Swing Traders. Identifies medium-term trends and potential reversal points, ideal for multi-day positions Click to see all.
Purpose 📈
The primary purpose or application of the trading indicatorMcGinley Dynamic Indicator- Trend IdentificationMcGinley Dynamic Indicator is primarily used for Trend Identification. Tools that help traders recognize and confirm established market trends Click to see all.
- Support/ResistanceMcGinley Dynamic Indicator is primarily used for Support/Resistance. Indicators that highlight price levels where trends may stall or reverse Click to see all.
Parabolic SARElder Impulse System- Entry/Exit PointsElder Impulse System is primarily used for Entry/Exit Points. Indicators for optimal trade entry and exit Click to see all.
- Trend ConfirmationElder Impulse System is primarily used for Trend Confirmation. Indicators that validate the strength and direction of price movements Click to see all.
Evaluation Comparison
Pros 👍
Advantages of using the trading indicatorMcGinley Dynamic Indicator- Adapts Quickly To Price Changes
- Reduces Whipsaws In Trending MarketsMinimizes false signals during strong trends, improving trend-following strategies
Parabolic SAR- Provides Clear Entry/Exit SignalsOffers precise timing for opening and closing trades, enhancing trade management
- Works Well In Trending MarketsIndicators that excel at identifying and confirming strong market trends
Elder Impulse System- Easy To Interpret Color-Coded Signals
- Combines Trend And Momentum
Cons 👎
Disadvantages or limitations of the trading indicatorMcGinley Dynamic Indicator- Less Known Than Traditional Moving AveragesDescribes indicators that are not as popular as traditional moving averages in technical analysis. Click to see all.
- Can Still Lag In Sharp Reversals
Parabolic SAR- Prone To Whipsaws In Ranging Markets
Elder Impulse System- Can Produce False Signals In Ranging Markets
- Requires Understanding Of Multiple Indicators
Performance Metrics Comparison
Reliability Score 💯
A score indicating the overall reliability of the trading indicatorMcGinley Dynamic IndicatorParabolic SARElder Impulse SystemEase of Use Score 💻
A score representing how user-friendly and intuitive the trading indicator isMcGinley Dynamic IndicatorParabolic SARElder Impulse SystemVersatility Score 🔀
A score indicating the adaptability of the trading indicator across different markets and timeframesMcGinley Dynamic IndicatorParabolic SARElder Impulse SystemCustomization Score 🔧
A score representing the degree of customization available for the trading indicatorMcGinley Dynamic Indicator- 6.5The customization score for McGinley Dynamic Indicator is 6.5 out of 10.
Parabolic SAR- 6The customization score for Parabolic SAR is 6 out of 10.
Elder Impulse System- 6The customization score for Elder Impulse System is 6 out of 10.
Score ⭐
The overall score of the trading indicator based on various performance metricsMcGinley Dynamic IndicatorParabolic SARElder Impulse System
Alternatives to McGinley Dynamic Indicator
Average Directional Index (ADX)
Known for Trend Strength Without Direction
💯
is more reliable than McGinley Dynamic Indicator
🔀
is more versatile than McGinley Dynamic Indicator
⭐
is rated higher overall than McGinley Dynamic Indicator
Volume Weighted Moving Average (VWMA)
Known for Incorporating Volume Into Moving Averages
🔀
is more versatile than McGinley Dynamic Indicator
Aroon Up And Down
Known for Identifying Potential Trend Changes
💻
is easier to use than McGinley Dynamic Indicator
🔀
is more versatile than McGinley Dynamic Indicator
⭐
is rated higher overall than McGinley Dynamic Indicator
Guppy Multiple Moving Average
Known for Visualizing Short-Term And Long-Term Trends
🔀
is more versatile than McGinley Dynamic Indicator
🔧
is more customizable than McGinley Dynamic Indicator
⭐
is rated higher overall than McGinley Dynamic Indicator
Force Index
Known for Combining Price Changes With Volume
🔀
is more versatile than McGinley Dynamic Indicator
Linear Regression Indicator
Known for Predicting Price Trends
🔀
is more versatile than McGinley Dynamic Indicator
Directional Movement Index (DMI)
Known for Strength Of Price Movement
💯
is more reliable than McGinley Dynamic Indicator
🔀
is more versatile than McGinley Dynamic Indicator
🔧
is more customizable than McGinley Dynamic Indicator
⭐
is rated higher overall than McGinley Dynamic Indicator
Chande Momentum Oscillator (CMO)
Known for Momentum Measurement
🔀
is more versatile than McGinley Dynamic Indicator
🔧
is more customizable than McGinley Dynamic Indicator
⭐
is rated higher overall than McGinley Dynamic Indicator
Vortex Indicator (VI)
Known for Trend Reversal Detection
💻
is easier to use than McGinley Dynamic Indicator
Moving Average Convergence Divergence (MACD)
Known for Trend Strength And Direction
💻
is easier to use than McGinley Dynamic Indicator
🔀
is more versatile than McGinley Dynamic Indicator
🔧
is more customizable than McGinley Dynamic Indicator
⭐
is rated higher overall than McGinley Dynamic Indicator