McGinley Dynamic Indicator vs Parabolic SAR vs Elder Impulse System
Compact mode

McGinley Dynamic Indicator vs Parabolic SAR vs Elder Impulse System

Table of content

General Information Comparison

Characteristics Comparison

Facts Comparison

  • Interesting Fact 💡
    An intriguing or lesser-known fact about the trading indicator
    McGinley Dynamic Indicator
    • Developed by John R. McGinley to address the lag in traditional moving averages
    Parabolic SAR
    • SAR stands for "Stop And Reverse"
    Elder Impulse System
    • Created by Dr. Alexander Elder a renowned trading psychologist

  • Sarcastic Fact 😉
    A humorous or ironic observation about the trading indicator
    McGinley Dynamic Indicator
    • So smooth it might make other indicators jealous
    Parabolic SAR
    • It's like a clingy ex - always trying to catch up with the price
    Elder Impulse System
    • Traffic light for traders: green means go red means stop blue means nap time

Application Comparison

  • Timeframe 🕑
    The time intervals or periods for which the trading indicator is most effective or commonly used.
    For all*
    • Daily
      Indicators optimized for daily chart analysis, suitable for swing and position traders.
    McGinley Dynamic Indicator
    • Weekly
      McGinley Dynamic Indicator is most effective for Weekly timeframes. Indicators optimized for weekly chart analysis, balancing short-term noise and long-term trends.
    Parabolic SAR
    • 1-Hour
      Parabolic SAR is most effective for 1-Hour timeframes. Indicators optimized for analyzing market data on a 1-hour timeframe
    • 4-Hour
      Parabolic SAR is most effective for 4-Hour timeframes. Indicators designed for analyzing market data on a 4-hour timeframe
    Elder Impulse System
    • Weekly
      Elder Impulse System is most effective for Weekly timeframes. Indicators optimized for weekly chart analysis, balancing short-term noise and long-term trends.

Technical Details Comparison

Usage Comparison

Evaluation Comparison

  • Pros 👍
    Advantages of using the trading indicator
    McGinley Dynamic Indicator
    • Adapts Quickly To Price Changes
    • Reduces Whipsaws In Trending Markets
      Minimizes false signals during strong trends, improving trend-following strategies
    Parabolic SAR
    • Provides Clear Entry/Exit Signals
      Offers precise timing for opening and closing trades, enhancing trade management
    • Works Well In Trending Markets
      Indicators that excel at identifying and confirming strong market trends
    Elder Impulse System
    • Easy To Interpret Color-Coded Signals
    • Combines Trend And Momentum

  • Cons 👎
    Disadvantages or limitations of the trading indicator
    McGinley Dynamic Indicator
    Parabolic SAR
    • Prone To Whipsaws In Ranging Markets
    Elder Impulse System
    • Can Produce False Signals In Ranging Markets
    • Requires Understanding Of Multiple Indicators

Performance Metrics Comparison

Alternatives to McGinley Dynamic Indicator
Price Channel
Known for Range-Bound Trading
💻 is easier to use than Parabolic SAR
⭐ is rated higher overall than Parabolic SAR
Linear Regression Indicator
Known for Predicting Price Trends
🔀 is more versatile than Parabolic SAR
Average Directional Index (ADX)
Known for Trend Strength Without Direction
💯 is more reliable than Parabolic SAR
🔀 is more versatile than Parabolic SAR
🔧 is more customizable than Parabolic SAR
⭐ is rated higher overall than Parabolic SAR
Vortex Indicator (VI)
Known for Trend Reversal Detection
💻 is easier to use than Parabolic SAR
Zigzag Indicator
Known for Filtering Market Noise
🔀 is more versatile than Parabolic SAR
🔧 is more customizable than Parabolic SAR
⭐ is rated higher overall than Parabolic SAR
Heikin Ashi Candlesticks
Known for Smoothing Price Action
💻 is easier to use than Parabolic SAR
🔀 is more versatile than Parabolic SAR
⭐ is rated higher overall than Parabolic SAR
Slow Stochastic
Known for Momentum Measurement
💯 is more reliable than Parabolic SAR
⭐ is rated higher overall than Parabolic SAR
Moving Average Envelope
Known for Price Range Visualization
💯 is more reliable than Parabolic SAR
💻 is easier to use than Parabolic SAR
🔀 is more versatile than Parabolic SAR
🔧 is more customizable than Parabolic SAR
⭐ is rated higher overall than Parabolic SAR
Donchian Channels
Known for Simplicity And Effectiveness
💯 is more reliable than Parabolic SAR
💻 is easier to use than Parabolic SAR
🔀 is more versatile than Parabolic SAR
🔧 is more customizable than Parabolic SAR
⭐ is rated higher overall than Parabolic SAR
Directional Movement Index (DMI)
Known for Strength Of Price Movement
💯 is more reliable than Parabolic SAR
🔀 is more versatile than Parabolic SAR
🔧 is more customizable than Parabolic SAR
⭐ is rated higher overall than Parabolic SAR