Compact mode
Volume Oscillator vs McClellan Oscillator vs Commitment Of Traders (COT)
Table of content
General Information Comparison
Indicator Type 📊
The category or classification of the trading indicator based on its primary function and analysis method.Volume Oscillator- VolumeVolume Oscillator is a Volume type indicator. Indicators that analyze trading volume to confirm price movements
McClellan OscillatorCommitment of Traders (COT)- SentimentCommitment of Traders (COT) is a Sentiment type indicator. Indicators that measure market sentiment and trader emotions
Asset Class 💰
Specifies the financial instruments for which the indicator is most commonly usedVolume Oscillator- StocksThe asset classes Volume Oscillator is typically used for are Stocks. Indicators optimized for analyzing and predicting stock price movements in equity markets. Click to see all.
- CommoditiesThe asset classes Volume Oscillator is typically used for are Commodities. Trading indicators optimized for commodity markets like oil, gold, and agricultural products. Click to see all.
- FuturesThe asset classes Volume Oscillator is typically used for are Futures. Indicators designed for trading futures contracts across various asset classes. Click to see all.
McClellan OscillatorCommitment of Traders (COT)- FuturesThe asset classes Commitment of Traders (COT) is typically used for are Futures. Indicators designed for trading futures contracts across various asset classes. Click to see all.
- CommoditiesThe asset classes Commitment of Traders (COT) is typically used for are Commodities. Trading indicators optimized for commodity markets like oil, gold, and agricultural products. Click to see all.
Known for 💭
The unique selling point or distinguishing feature of the trading indicatorVolume Oscillator- Volume DivergenceVolume Oscillator is known for Volume Divergence.
McClellan Oscillator- Identifying Market TrendsMcClellan Oscillator is known for Identifying Market Trends.
Commitment of Traders (COT)- Insight Into Institutional PositioningCommitment of Traders (COT) is known for Insight Into Institutional Positioning.
Made In 🌍
The country or origin of the trading indicatorVolume Oscillator- United StatesVolume Oscillator was developed in United States. Indicators developed in the USA, reflecting American trading principles
McClellan Oscillator- United StatesMcClellan Oscillator was developed in United States. Indicators developed in the USA, reflecting American trading principles
Commitment of Traders (COT)- USACommitment of Traders (COT) was developed in USA. Trading indicators developed by American market analysts
Characteristics Comparison
Lagging or Leading 🏁
Indicates whether the trading indicator is a lagging or leading type, reflecting its predictive nature.For all*Complexity Level 🧑
Indicates the level of expertise required to effectively use the indicatorVolume OscillatorMcClellan OscillatorCommitment of Traders (COT)Popularity 🏆
Indicates how widely used and recognized the indicator is in the trading communityFor all*- MediumIndicators with balanced adoption and potential effectiveness
Facts Comparison
Interesting Fact 💡
An intriguing or lesser-known fact about the trading indicatorVolume Oscillator- Combines elements of Moving Average Convergence Divergence (MACD) with volume
McClellan Oscillator- Created by Sherman and Marian McClellan in 1969
Commitment of Traders (COT)- Mandated by the Commodity Exchange Act in 1962
Sarcastic Fact 😉
A humorous or ironic observation about the trading indicatorVolume Oscillator- Often called the "heartbeat monitor" of the market
McClellan Oscillator- It's like taking the market's temperature with a fancy thermometer
Commitment of Traders (COT)- It's like peeking at the big players' cards - if only they weren't playing poker face!
Application Comparison
Timeframe 🕑
The time intervals or periods for which the trading indicator is most effective or commonly used.Volume Oscillator- DailyVolume Oscillator is most effective for Daily timeframes. Indicators optimized for daily chart analysis, suitable for swing and position traders.
- WeeklyVolume Oscillator is most effective for Weekly timeframes. Indicators optimized for weekly chart analysis, balancing short-term noise and long-term trends.
McClellan Oscillator- DailyMcClellan Oscillator is most effective for Daily timeframes. Indicators optimized for daily chart analysis, suitable for swing and position traders.
Commitment of Traders (COT)- WeeklyCommitment of Traders (COT) is most effective for Weekly timeframes. Indicators optimized for weekly chart analysis, balancing short-term noise and long-term trends.
Technical Details Comparison
Calculation Method 🧮
The mathematical or analytical approach used to compute the trading indicator's values.For all*Signal Generation 📊
Describes the methods by which the indicator produces trading signalsVolume Oscillator- CrossoversVolume Oscillator generates trading signals through Crossovers. Indicators that generate signals when one line crosses another, indicating trend changes
McClellan Oscillator- CrossoversMcClellan Oscillator generates trading signals through Crossovers. Indicators that generate signals when one line crosses another, indicating trend changes
- ThresholdsMcClellan Oscillator generates trading signals through Thresholds. Indicators that generate signals when certain predefined levels or conditions are met
Commitment of Traders (COT)- Position ChangesCommitment of Traders (COT) generates trading signals through Position Changes. Indicators that signal when to alter trading positions based on market conditions
- ExtremesCommitment of Traders (COT) generates trading signals through Extremes. Indicators that identify overbought or oversold conditions in the market
Customization Options 🔧
Lists the parameters that can be adjusted to fine-tune the indicatorVolume Oscillator- PeriodVolume Oscillator offers customization options for Period. Enables customization of analysis timeframe Click to see all.
- SmoothingVolume Oscillator offers customization options for Smoothing. Adjustable smoothing for noise reduction Click to see all.
McClellan OscillatorCommitment of Traders (COT)- Report CategoriesCommitment of Traders (COT) offers customization options for Report Categories. Enables customization of analysis report types or sections Click to see all.
- Time PeriodsCommitment of Traders (COT) offers customization options for Time Periods. Customizable multiple time periods for analysis Click to see all.
Usage Comparison
For whom 👥
The target audience or user group for the trading indicatorVolume OscillatorMcClellan OscillatorCommitment of Traders (COT)- Institutional TradersCommitment of Traders (COT) is designed for Institutional Traders. Tailored for large-scale trading decisions and portfolio management Click to see all.
- Commodity AnalystsCommitment of Traders (COT) is designed for Commodity Analysts. Specialized tools for analyzing trends and patterns in commodity markets Click to see all.
Purpose 📈
The primary purpose or application of the trading indicatorVolume Oscillator- Volume Trend IdentificationVolume Oscillator is primarily used for Volume Trend Identification.
McClellan OscillatorCommitment of Traders (COT)- Market Sentiment AnalysisCommitment of Traders (COT) is primarily used for Market Sentiment Analysis. Indicators that gauge overall market mood and psychology Click to see all.
- Long-Term Trend PredictionCommitment of Traders (COT) is primarily used for Long-Term Trend Prediction. Indicators that excel at forecasting extended market movements Click to see all.
Evaluation Comparison
Pros 👍
Advantages of using the trading indicatorVolume Oscillator- Helps Confirm Price Movements With VolumeIndicators that validate price changes by analyzing trading volume
- Useful For Spotting Fake Breakouts
McClellan Oscillator- Effective For Overall Market AnalysisIndicators providing broad insights into overall market conditions
- Good For Timing Entries/Exits
Commitment of Traders (COT)- Provides Insight Into Big Players' PositionsHelps track large-scale market participants' activities, aiding in strategy alignment
- Useful For Long-Term AnalysisIndicators suited for analyzing extended time periods and identifying major trends
- Free Data From CFTCIndicators utilizing freely available data from the Commodity Futures Trading Commission
Cons 👎
Disadvantages or limitations of the trading indicatorVolume Oscillator- Can Be Less Effective In Low-Volume Markets
- Requires Understanding Of Volume AnalysisDescribes indicators that need knowledge of volume interpretation for effective use. Click to see all.
McClellan Oscillator- Specific To Stock MarketsIndicates that some indicators are designed primarily for stock market analysis. Click to see all.
- Complex CalculationIndicators with straightforward calculations and easy-to-understand outputs for efficient analysis Click to see all.
Commitment of Traders (COT)- Weekly Reporting Lag
- Complex Interpretation
- Limited To Futures Markets
Performance Metrics Comparison
Reliability Score 💯
A score indicating the overall reliability of the trading indicatorVolume OscillatorMcClellan OscillatorCommitment of Traders (COT)Ease of Use Score 💻
A score representing how user-friendly and intuitive the trading indicator isVolume OscillatorMcClellan OscillatorCommitment of Traders (COT)Versatility Score 🔀
A score indicating the adaptability of the trading indicator across different markets and timeframesVolume OscillatorMcClellan OscillatorCommitment of Traders (COT)Customization Score 🔧
A score representing the degree of customization available for the trading indicatorVolume Oscillator- 7The customization score for Volume Oscillator is 7 out of 10.
McClellan Oscillator- 6.5The customization score for McClellan Oscillator is 6.5 out of 10.
Commitment of Traders (COT)- 6.5The customization score for Commitment of Traders (COT) is 6.5 out of 10.
Score ⭐
The overall score of the trading indicator based on various performance metricsVolume OscillatorMcClellan OscillatorCommitment of Traders (COT)
Alternatives to Volume Oscillator
Chaikin Oscillator
Known for Accumulation/Distribution Trends
💯
is more reliable than Volume Oscillator
💻
is easier to use than Volume Oscillator
🔧
is more customizable than Volume Oscillator
⭐
is rated higher overall than Volume Oscillator
Aroon Up And Down
Known for Identifying Potential Trend Changes
💻
is easier to use than Volume Oscillator
Aroon Indicator
Known for Measuring Time Between Highs And Lows
💯
is more reliable than Volume Oscillator
💻
is easier to use than Volume Oscillator
⭐
is rated higher overall than Volume Oscillator
Directional Movement Index (DMI)
Known for Strength Of Price Movement
💯
is more reliable than Volume Oscillator
🔧
is more customizable than Volume Oscillator
⭐
is rated higher overall than Volume Oscillator
Commodity Channel Index (CCI)
Known for Identifying Cyclical Trends
💻
is easier to use than Volume Oscillator
Know Sure Thing (KST)
Known for Trend Strength Measurement
🔧
is more customizable than Volume Oscillator